Society
has basic standards that are fairly uniform. Lying, cheating, and breaking the law don’t
fall within those values. There is no
line above which it’s wrong a person to do something and below which it's okay
for another to do the same thing. That
would be a double standard (or situational ethics.)
We
hold our politicians, family members,
accountants, doctors, dentists, spouses, and children accountable, and
professional associates to certain standards. World and national figures live or die by
their behaviors.
No
one disputes that Lance Armstrong should have been outed for cheating. He did not deserve to hold the titles that he
cheated to obtain. Those who spoke up
and told the truth did the right thing. Insiders knew for years what he
was doing, but no one was willing to pull the trigger until now.
Well
known public figures, Harriet Klausner and Lance Armstrong, have a lot in
common:
Lance Armstrong is a widely recognized world figure.
Harriet Klausner is a widely recognized national figure.
Lance Armstrong and his team won the Tour de
France 7 times.
Harriet Klausner was Amazon’s No. 1 reviewer for
11 years.
Lance Armstrong cheated and lied to achieve his extraordinary feats.
Harriet Klausner has cheated and lied to achieve her extraordinary feats.
Lance Armstrong received endorsements as a result of his status in the
biking world.
Harriet Klausner received endorsements as a result of her status in the reviewing
world.
Lance Armstrong’s behavior violated the law and sporting world
standards.
Harriet Klausner’s behavior violates the law and industry standards.
Armstrong “earned” a lot of money as a result of his standing in the
sporting world.
Klausner has “earned” a lot of money as a result of her standing in the
publishing industry.
Lance Armstrong denied allegations of doping for
10 years.
Harriet Klausner has denied allegations of fraud
for 11 years.
Armstrong’s behavior has harmed the credibility of athletes and the sports world
everywhere.
Harriet Klausner’s behavior has harmed the credibility of
reviewers and the industry.
Will
Lance Armstrong ever be believed again? No.
Should Hariet Klausner ever be believed again? No.
Can
Lance Armstrong continue to bike? Yes,
but as a pastime.
Can
Harriet Klausner continue to read and review books: Yes, but as a pastime.
When
we allow lying, cheating, and deception to occur by passively turning a blind
eye, we actively participate in the diminution of our societal values and the
decline of our society. We make the world a better place when we fight to
do the right thing.
1 comment:
Here's something else I hope Hattie and Lance Armstrong will soon have in common:
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/23/sports/cycling/armstrong-stripped-of-his-7-tour-de-france-titles.html?ref=sports&_r=0
(Obviously HK didn't win any Tours de France. But I'm sure you can come up with your own analogy.)
Post a Comment